Kathy Maister's Start Cooking

The Ultimate Guide to Cooking a Thanksgiving Turkey

posted in Meat, Poultry and Seafood by Kathy Maister

cooking a turkey

Welcome to startcooking’s ultimate (and updated) guide to cooking a turkey!

The thought of cooking your very first Thanksgiving dinner can be a bit intimidating, but with just a bit of advance planning you can definitely pull it off. Roasting a turkey is very similar to roasting a chicken except your oven temperature should be set at 325 degrees and not 400 degrees. Go have a look at that video of mine before you begin. The USDA’s Fact Sheet on Poultry Preparation is also an excellent resource. It includes information on buying, defrosting, cooking, storing, and an emergency hot-line to call for advice as well!

This post will cover the following 10 questions:

  1. What kind of turkey should you buy – fresh, frozen, whole, or just the breast?
  2. What size should I buy?
  3. What’s that stuff already inside my turkey and do I eat it?
  4. What kind of pan do I need to cook the turkey and for how long?
  5. Is making stove-top stuffing cheating or should I stuff the turkey?
  6. Should I make gravy from scratch or just buy it?
  7. Now that the turkey is cooked, how do I carve it?
  8. Is turkey healthy and why am I so tired after eating it?
  9. Is there a turkey hot-line for emergency questions?
  10. What kind of side dishes do I need and how about some dessert?
  11. What do I do with all those turkey leftover?

1. What Kind of Turkey Should You Buy; Fresh, Frozen, Whole, or Just the Breast?

Fresh Turkey

If your guests are coming tomorrow, you will need to buy a fresh (not frozen) turkey. If you have time to plan in advance, you can reserve a fresh turkey ahead of time, from your local butcher shop (if you have one!)

Frozen Turkey

Frozen turkies need time to defrost. The fastest way to defrost a frozen turkey is to put it (in its original packaging) in the sink and let it soak in COLD water. Be sure the turkey is completely covered with water. Change the water every half hour. Allow one hour of thawing time per pound of turkey. If you have the time, typically a couple of days, you can thaw your turkey in your refrigerator. Calculate five hours of thawing time per pound.

Whole or Breast of Turkey

That depends on your own personal tastes. One year, I decided to just buy and cook turkey breasts figuring it would be easier to carve and serve. Everyone asked where the legs were! You can buy whole turkeys that are “self-basting”. They are moist and delicious and I would highly recommend them for the beginning cook.

(Note: Don’t be concerned if your turkey does not come out looking like the ones on the cover of all the food magazines. Photographers sometime use shoe polish to make those turkeys have that beautiful coloring!)

2. What Turkey Size Should I Buy?

Calculate one pound per person. So, for a group of six, a six-pound turkey should suffice. Go for one that’s bigger if you want to have leftovers.

3. What’s that Already Stuffed in my Turkey and Do I Eat It?

When you remove the turkey from its wrapping you will have to reach into the cavity and remove the bag that’s inside before you cook the turkey.

(I show this in my Roasted Chicken video and — yes — there is an “ick” factor here!) The bag usually contains the neck, liver and various edible innards of the turkey. These parts can be simmered in seasoned water on the stove. They are then strained and the flavored water is used as stock to make the gravy. (Pioneer Woman shows how to do this here.) If this is the first turkey you have ever cooked, I am going to recommend tossing this bag away and using store-bought gravy.

4. What Kind of Pan Do I Need to Cook the Turkey and How Long Do I Cook It?

The Pan

A roasting pan with a V-shaped rack is your best bet – but they are expensive. The rack elevates the turkey, allowing the juices and fat to drip into the pan.

A less expensive alternative is to buy a disposable roasting pan from the grocery store.

To give a disposable roasting pan a bit of stability, it is best to place it on a baking sheet with sides.

You can make your own rack by coiling a strip of tin foil.

How long do I cook it?

Read the directions on the package of the turkey and be sure to write down the weight of the turkey. (I even cut out the cooking chart and put it on a plate for reference…just in case!)

Many turkeys come with a single use thermometer that pops up when the turkey is done. You can also use your own meat thermometer or you can buy a single use pop-up thermometer. (I prefer instant read thermometers) I explain more about thermometers here.

If you are using a regular meat thermometer, insert it about 2.5 inches into the deepest part of the turkey, without touching the bone.

The minimum internal temperature should reach 165°F.

“A whole turkey (and turkey parts) is safe to eat when cooked to a minimum internal temperature of 165°F as measured with a food thermometer. Check the internal temperature in the innermost part of the thigh and wing and the thickest part of the breast. For reasons of personal preference, consumers may choose to cook turkey to higher temperatures.”

Prior to 2006, (as per recommendation of the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service) most cookbooks recommended that the internal temperature of a turkey should reach 170 degrees F in the breast or 180 degrees F in the thigh. If you cook your turkey that long it will end up dry and tough.

For a good visual to determine if your turkey is cooked, make a slice by the leg joint to see if the juices run clear. The joint should feel loose.

An unstuffed turkey takes less time to cook than a stuffed turkey. Butterball has a great site that will help you to determine the cooking time of your turkey.

5. Is Making Stove-Top Stuffing Cheating or Should I Stuff the Turkey?

Bread stuffing (with gravy) is one of my favorite parts of this meal. Instant stove-top stuffing is surprisingly tasty. This stuffing uses dried bread croutons and you can add chopped celery and onions if you like. (That’s how my mom used to make stuffing!)

Make the stuffing and bake it in the oven (or on the stove top). You do not have to stuff the turkey. In fact the USFDA advises against this method for food-safety reasons. The unstuffed turkey will take less time to cook.

6. Should I make gravy from scratch or just buy it?

As I said above, if this is the first turkey you have ever cooked, I am going to recommend using store-bought gravy. Making gravy is not difficult but it can be tricky for a beginner cook. If you are considering making your own gravy from scratch, start by checking out my post on How to Make Gravy. There are several different ways to go about making gravy. Here are some additional links to really good photo tutorials and videos on making various kinds of gravy:

  • Epicurious has an excellent video on How to Make Gravy by deglazing a roasting pan first.
  • The Mayo Clinic also has an excellent video on Making Healthy Gravy. Their recipe uses cornstarch instead of butter and flour to thicken the gravy.
  • Instructables has a great photo-tutorial on a superb looking Vegetarian Mushroom Gravy.
  • For lovers of Giblet Gravy, head over to Cook Like Your Grandmother for a very well done photo-tutorial.
  • Martha Stewarts Perfect Gravy is made with Madera Wine. She thickens her gravy by making a “slurry” of giblet stock and flour in a jar.

7. Now that the Turkey Is Cooked, How Do I Carve It?

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_2931A.JPG

Once the turkey is out of the oven, loosely cover it with tin foil and let it rest at least 20 minutes to 30 minutes. When carving the turkey, make sure you have a sharp knife and be sure to carve it in the kitchen – not at the dinner table. Any spills or mishaps should happen behind closed doors. Garnish the turkey platter with lots of fresh parsley and maybe even some sliced oranges. (By the way, there are about 65,000 videos on Google showing you how to carve a turkey!)

8. Is Turkey Healthy and Why Am I so Tired After Eating It?

Turkey is a great source of protein but the l-tryptophan can make you sleepy. Or maybe it’s just that you worked so hard preparing your first, utterly fantastic, turkey dinner!

9. Is There a Turkey Hot-Line for Emergency Questions?

Of course! And there are real people on the other end of the phoneline!

10. What Kind of Side Dishes Do I Need and What About Dessert?

Startcooking.com has tons of appetizers, side dishes and desserts to choose from. Here are just a few suggestions:

Pumpkin Soup

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_9401.JPG

Cranberry Sauce with Mandarian Oranges

http://startcooking.com/public/images/IMG_0449.JPG

Mashed potatoes

http://startcooking.com/public/images/imgp2837_305.jpg

Gravy (from a jar) or Make Your Own Gravy

Sweet Potato Casserole

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_6231.jpg

Butternut squash

http://startcooking.com/public/images/IMG_0762.JPG

Steamed fresh vegetables

http://startcooking.com/public/images/IMG_9235.JPG

And for dessert how about Pecan Pie!

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_9931.JPG

Pumpkin Pie

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_9327.JPG

Chocolate Cheese Cake Pie

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_4214.jpg

11. What Do I Do with all Those Turkey Leftover?

Cooked turkey can be substituted for any recipe that calls for cooked chicken.

Chicken (or turkey) Salad with Wild Rice and Avocados (video) can get made in the morning and dinner will be ready and waiting when you get home from work (or shopping!).

Chicken (or turkey) Noodle Soup is everyone’s favorite. This recipe takes less than 20 minutes to prepare.

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_1113.JPG

Chicken (or turkey) Salad is great made with walnuts and grapes!

http://startcooking.com/public/IMG_4984.JPG

Caesar Salad often has cooked chicken add so why not some cooked turkey!

http://startcooking.com/public/images/IMG_8558.JPG

Taste of Home definitely knows what to do with their turkey leftovers. They have a great list of the Top 10 Things to do with Leftover Turkey.

Kate’s Global Kitchen does something really cool called:Turkey 3 Ingredients = Luscious Leftovers

Jennie-O as well as HubPages both have some great tips how to store your leftovers and how long they will keep.

Good Luck and Happy Holidays!

If you are new to startcooking, or are a regular visitor here, please consider subscribing for free.

41 Comments

Justin said:

The turkey hotline is so cool!

I can’t believe that exists.

Jon said:

The turkey hotline appeared in the first (I think) series of the West Wing!

will said:

no stuffing in the turkey?

ah non non non non ce n’est pas possible, je suis desolé!

I don`t buy that USFDA advice for one single grandmother-minute! Time tested and honored.Generations of people have been Stuffing a turkey from time immemorial, or at least the mid 1900s. :)

I think a qucik stuffing — the knd you buy in a store and add a few things to, are easy and fine for the startcooking crowd.

and it`s so rewarding… because it tastes so good, and makes one feel so warm inside,

I vote for stuffing.

Kathy Maister said:

I’m not sure, but I do believe the Turkey Hot Line has been around for at least 20 years! I have actually called it :) and the folks answering the phone could not have been nicer!

Oh Will, I am so sorry you disagree with the USFDA! (I do particularly like that crispy crust the stuffing develops peeking out of the turkey but….) For a first timer, I’m still recommending the stuffing be made and cooked outside of the bird! :)

will said:

I would like to know what people’s favorite side dishes are.

One of mine is simply baby carrots and pearl onions:

  • baby carrots
  • pearl onions
  • parsley
  • butter
  • salt pepper
  • brown sugar to taste

in a pan with medium heat, I fry up some frozen pearl onions for a couple minutes, throw in the carrots and seasoning, and steam covered with with just a little bit of water at the bottom. I throw in the parsley at the very last minute, and always the flat leaf kind: I think it is less sour and more fragrant.

Jon said:

Red cabbage, roast potatoes (of course), roast parsnips. glazed carrots ….

Oh and bread sauce

Kathy Maister said:

Jon, what’s bread sauce? Will, your carrots sound great!
I grew up with at least one Thanksgiving side dish made with (Campbell’s) Cream of Mushroom soup. My favorite was to:

  • dilute the soup with about ½ can of cream
  • mix in two jars of drained pearl onions
  • add a handful of walnuts
  • top with cheddar cheese and
  • bake until bubbly at 350 degrees (about 30 minutes).

Delicious!

Jon said:

I did wonder whether bread sauce was a British thing:

As Deliah saysTraditional bread sauce is one of the great, classic British sauces… The real thing is beautifully creamy and the perfect accompaniment to chicken or turkey.

Ingredients

1 small onion, finely chopped

½ tsp ground cloves

2 fresh bay leaves

568ml fresh whole milk

50g butter, plus knob of butter to finish (optional)

200g day old white bread, crusts removed

½ tsp freshly grated nutmeg

4 tbsp double cream

Method

  1. Place the onion and ground cloves in a small pan. Tear the bay leaves in half and add to the pan with the milk and butter. Season generously with pepper. Bring to the boil, then reduce the heat and allow to simmer gently for 20 minutes, until the onion has softened. Remove from heat and leave to infuse for 1 hour or chill overnight.
  2. Remove and discard the bay leaves. Roughly tear the bread into even-sized pieces, then stir into the milk with a wooden spoon. Add the nutmeg and season. Return to the heat and simmer for a further 3-4 minutes. Stir in the cream and serve warm. A knob of butter on the top will stop a skin from forming.

ENJOY

will said:

Wow, your pearl onions walnut combo kathy sounds just incredible, I for-sure am going to try that.

susan said:

Horror story? Just this: finding the blade from the grinder in the bowl of stuffing. Giving thanks that I was the one who got it.

gaurav said:

Do I need to use cesar salt for a raosting a “self-basting” Turkey? yes, it’s going to be the first time..hopefully.

Peter said:

Question about bread stuffing. How far in advance can you make it to be safe?

Kathy Maister said:

Thanks Jon for the bread sauce recipe. It even sounds English! Here in the USA I don’t think I’ve ever seen the term “knob of butter” used. I love it!

Susan, your story is really (really) scary!

Gaurav, it is not necessary to use seasoned salt. Just regular salt and pepper is fine for seasoning a turkey.

Peter, your stuffing should be just fine made the day before Thanksgiving.

Good Luck to everyone making their first turkey dinner!

Kathy Maister said:

News Flash! Temperature Change!

“The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service announced a change in the “Single Minimum Internal Temperature Established for Cooked Poultry”. The new cooking recommendation is as follows:

“A whole turkey (and turkey parts) is safe when cooked to a minimum internal temperature of 165°F as measured with a food thermometer. Check the internal temperature in the innermost part of the thigh and wing and the thickest part of the breast. For reasons of personal preference, consumers may choose to cook turkey to higher temperatures.”

This new cooking temperature is a change from previous 180°F for a whole turkey and 170°F for turkey breast. The single minimum internal temperature change to 165°F was recommended by the National Advisory Committee on Microbiological Criteria for Foods (NACMCF) in a press release in 2006.”

wooden trays said:

it’s going to be the first time..hopefully.

gaurav said:

I bought a frozen turkey breast ~ 7 lb. I’m planing to brine it before roasting. On the brine bag it says brine for 20-24 hours. I checked on a website where they’re advising brining for ~ 12 hrs. What should I do?

Kathy Maister said:

Good Luck Wooden Tray!

Guarav, follow the instructions on the brine bag. The more you keep comparing recipes the more confusing it may get! Call the Turkey Hot Line if you get stuck!

Lisa Freeman said:

Hi Gaurav! I’m so thrilled you mentioned brining! I’m bringing my 14 pound turkey, too. I’ve done this for the last three years and it comes out way juicier than not brining in my opinion.

Definitely leave it in there for 24 full hours. That’s what everyone recommends, especially the king of brining–Alton Brown on the Food Network. I don’t recommend less than that! It is not going to hurt your turkey despite what that website you read says. Just make sure that you’ve got plenty of ice in there, and check the temp often.

Can’t wait to hear how your first brining experience goes! You’ll definitely have a juicier bird!

gaurav said:

I’m so excited…everbody on here is so helpful…The bird is otu getting thawed

Melissa said:

I am a first-time thanksgiving chef this year and I AM VERY NERVOUS ABOUT THE TURKEY. I am cooking 2 Turkey breast in my electric roaster. I have heard several different things but i want to run it by some other people. My plan is to just carve the turkey in the kitchen and serve it on a platter. Everyone always says ” cook it breast up,” but my mom says that she cooks hers breast down in a slow cooker because the breast meat will be more juicy.

Also, does any one have a simple Baked dressing recipe?

gaurav said:

mroe questions…I am going to brine the bird. Do I still need to rub/sprinkle the turkey with kosher/seasonal salt before roasting (as indicated in the video above)?

Lisa Freeman said:

Yes! Seasoning your bird is a different issue than brining. Some people mistakenly believe that because the bird is sitting in salt-water that it takes on a heavily salty taste, and this is completely untrue. The ratio to salt in the water is not terribly high, so it does not impact your bird with a salty taste.

You should season your bird as indicated in Kathy’s video after you’re done with the brining. I’ve already popped mine in the brine in a 5 gallon bucket I bought at Home Depot for a few dollars. Of course, you want to make sure your container is new and clean and used only for a foodie purpose such as this. Don’t try to use a bucket that was used to store something else or you’ll risk contaminating your bird. Gaurav, you mentioned you turkey was 7 pounds, so that might be small enough to fit in a large pot you already have in your kitchen.

They key is to give the bird plenty of room and not try to cram it into whatever container you are using to brine it in.

Good luck with your bird!

PASHABELL said:

I HAVE JUST HEARD OF ROASTING A TURKEY @ 160 DEGREES BEGINNING AT SIX IN THE EVENING AND ROASTING THROUGH THE NIGHT…..DON’T KNOW HOW LONG FOR AN I8 TO 22 LB BIRD SHOULD ROAST AND I ASSUME I STUFF THE CAVITY AFTER IT GETS HOT , IS THIS AN ACCEPTABLE METHOD IT SOUND??????? IS THE TURKEY BETTER????? THANK YOU

Going2Oahu said:

Mahalo for these coking tips. I have cooked my turkey imu-style for the last 10 years but we have some company this year that wants a “traditional bird”.

Kathy Maister said:

Thanks Lisa! You are clearly THE turkey expert!

Gaurav and Melissa-Good Luck! I have no doubt your Thanksgiving turkeys witll be fantastic! (I’ll be keeping my fingers crossed for you!)

Lisa Freeman said:

Hi Melissa! I hope I’m not too late to help you out! I make the following apple and sausage baked stuffing (or dressing, as you refer to it). I buy the pork sausage in the supermarket in a big brick. I personally skip the walnuts, but you don’t have to if you like them. You could also check out this apple and raisin stuffing that’s right on the Pepperidge Farm website. If you’re in a pinch at this stage, just purchase your favorite brand of stuffing mix and buy the ingredients they suggest right on the bag and just follow them exactly.

I always cook my turkiey breast up. For one, I think it squishes the turkey breast and deforms it if it goes face down, plus the breast is the largest part and needs lots of exposure to the heat. But there are plenty of opinion of up or down as you mom has already suggested.

If you’re just cooking breasts (and you’re not telling us how large or small they are), your biggest concern is going to be dryness, as you don’t have the rest of the bird to pull moistness from–the breast always tend to be the dryest part of the bird.

What I do with a full bird, is that I cook it at 500 degrees F for 30 minutes to get the breast browned, and then I lower the temp to 350 and take aluminum foil and make a cover just for the breast (we call it the “breast plate of armor” at my house). Then we wait for the breast to hit 165 degrees on our thermometer.

You could do a variation of the same thing, except you would cover your whole pan with foil to seal in the moisture and prevent dried breasts.

But, you could also listen to your mom if her recipe is full-proof. I’ve never put a bird in a slow cooker, so I can’t attest if that actually works. But, it does sound like it works for her.

Let us know how your bird breasts turn out.

gaurav goel said:

Turkey came out great….juicy and delicious. Thanks all, esp. Lisa and Kathy for their helpful comments. I hope other’s had a good lazy thanksgiving too.

Lisa Freeman said:

Cool Gaurav! Glad to hear your bird came out great with the brining! Ours was fab too, and the leftovers the next day were still terrifically moist even after reheating.

Well, I’m sure we’ll all be chatting about our December holiday meal ideas shortly! I’m already planning a seafood feast.

Looking forward to hearing what others will be doing.

Kathy Maister said:

To Gaurav and everyone else who tried cooking their very first turkey…CONGRATULATIONS!

For many new cooks this is a huge first step in learning to cook and I am so very happy for all you!

Thanks for tuning to startcooking.com for help!

Melissa said:

My 1st Thanksgiving went GREAT!! I ended up cooking the (2) Turkey breast in the electric roaster with the breast down. It was perfect. Very Moist!!! I decided to go with a traditional bread dressing. I was worried for a minute but it turned out great.

It was quite a task because I have to be careful when I cook due to the fact that my husband is a severe diabetic so I always plan my meals around his diet, including Thanksgiving. the only thing he couldn’t eat waas the dressing but he really enjoyed everything else.

Jon (Sacker) said:

I just had to add this! I know that Thanksgiving is over, but here in the UK we eat our turkeys at Christmas (after all we don’t have Thanksgiving!).

Anyway our Food Standards Agency (a bit like the USDA) has warned very strongly against washing your turkey. Anyway here’s the story.

Jon

ellaella said:

Terrific post, Kathy. I wish I’d had a guide like this for my first (or second or third) Thanksgiving dinner and it’s a good refresher course for us all.

One thing I didn’t think of as a beginner is that the weight on the turkey’s label includes the neck and giblets, so my turkeys were always done sooner than I expected, which only added to the stress. Since then I deduct their weight and plan accordingly.

Happy Thanksgiving to you and everyone at Start Cooking!

Kathy Maister said:

WOW!

I never thought about that but you are totally right! Thanks for the great tip!

Happy Thanksgiving Ella!

kaz said:

Which way do you put a pan in the oven?? The length of the pan front to back or side to side?

WillB said:

Excellent post. It has been so long since I have cooked a turkey I had forgotten most of the things you put here. You rock!

Nyckee Hien said:

I am freaking out. This is my first year cooking a turkey and I have 15 people telling me 15 different things. I have a 13.71 lb turkey that is going to be brined in a savory turkey brine. I will be cooking in an electirc roaster with a turkey bag. I have no clue when to baste or how long to cook or even what to season this thing with. I am getting more and more confused. Can someone help me out or at least point me in the right direction?

startcooking.com said:

Hi Nyckee,
(Take a deep breath…)
Here is a link on how to cook a turkey in an electric roaster.
Epicurious has a great video on How to Brine a Turkey.
Brining a turkey makes it juicy, tender and tasty. I’m sure yours will be wonderful!
Good Luck!
Kathy

Elysia said:

I always stuff my turkey with celery, carrot and onion, just to help flavor the bird. Those are then thrown away and I serve dressing that I baked in a Casserole dish. I know people who have gotten food poisoning because the stuffing inside of the bird wasn’t full cooked.

startcooking.com said:

Hi Elsia, Yes adding the vegetables to the turkey cavity certainly does add to the flavor of the bird. I sometimes even put in a cut up orange or lemon.
K.

seth said:

I would still like to see a photo by photo guide to deep fried turkey.

David said:

Those side dishes look great too (soup, salad, and deserts), which only goes to remind me, that it is a total experience, and not just getting the meat right.